I've been following The Amazing Digital Circus since its first episode dropped in 2023. While initially drawn in by the fun animation and interesting premise, what kept me hooked was the character writing and the ways creator Gooseworx utilized her unique setting. As of a couple days ago, the series finale dropped, and with it has come a wave of discourse from people who... really seemed to miss the point, but that's not entirely what we're here to discuss today. Let's give this finale—and, to a certain degree, the series as a whole—a good old fashioned review.
The Discourse
The final episode, officially titled "Remember", has become the victim of some widespread discourse due to it not being what many fans were expecting. I've seen several complaints regarding the fact that the story's climax lacks any sort of action or spectacle, or that it feels aimless, or that "nothing happens". If it isn't clear, I think the people making these critiques are dumb.
While TADC has featured some very fun and interesting action in its previous episodes, that aspect of the show was never what it was really about. When asked directly about the show's themes on Tumblr, Gooseworx replied that the main takeaway of TADC is "That there's meaning to be found in a stagnant life." It's about the characters and the ways they cope with the terrible situation they're in.
In the penultimate episode, we see the cast come to terms with the fact that they're likely never going to escape the circus; this then leads into the reveal in the finale that they're brain scans, and thus fundamentally incapable of leaving. It's only by accepting themselves, coming to terms with their situation, and embracing each other that they can avoid abstraction and start to find meaning and happiness. This brings us to the one person who fails to do so,
Jax
Jax is a fascinating character, and probably my favorite in the show for how she is portrayed. While the episode doesn't say it outright, it's made exceedingly clear that Jax is a closeted trans woman, and this was confirmed by Gooseworx online. Her failure to come out even when transported into a new body and introduced to a new group of strangers is a testament to the sheer level of internalized shame from which she suffers. The mere thought that Ribbit figured out her identity is so cataclysmic to her that she completely shuts her best friend out and eventually leads to her abstraction.
Jax is an antagonist. She exists to serve as a foil to the story's heroes, to show what could have happened to them if they failed to come to terms with themselves and the circus. She is never able to accept herself, and that leads her down a depressive, antisocial spiral that eventually leads to her own abstraction. Jax's fate is tragic but, very importantly, entirely brought on by herself and her own failure to trust in other people or to pick healthy coping methods.
Another criticism I've seen quite a bit online is that it feels like the finale "wasted" a bunch of time on Jax's backstory when Pomni ultimately fails to save her; I think people are simply missing the point once again. The circus is a prison for its characters, an existential horror disguised as a wonderland. The primary object of the setting's horror is that, at any time, any of the people trapped within could lose their sense of self and abstract. If it were so easy to save Jax, that element of horror would be undercut, and the story's broader messages would lose a lot of their meaning. Furthermore, Pomni's inability to save Jax adds to the tragedy of her story. Abstracting is, at least in part, an allegory for suicide; it's fitting that, even if a part of her is still there, Jax still faces permanent consequences for her failures.
Personally, I also quite like that the ultimate fate of the abstracted individuals is left ambiguous. Pomni clearly does manage to get through to Jax, and it's shown that it's possible to calm down the abstraction monsters. TADC leaves it up to viewer interpretation whether the abstractees can eventually be saved or if they're stuck like that forever. The former provides a happy ending; the latter adds another layer to the idea of "finding meaning in a stagnant life", in this case tasking the abstractees with doing so even after they're no longer themselves.
Another thing I really appreciate about Jax is that she isn't a good person. As mentioned above, she brought her fate upon herself, and she's also directly responsible for Ribbit's abstraction. She serves as an antagonistic force throughout the entire series. Trans rep is relatively rare, so when series do include trans characters, they tend to be overly sanitized, sometimes not even feeling like real people because they need to be "pure" to serve as "good rep". I'm really glad that Gooseworx was brave enough to give us a trans woman who's just a total asshole.
Caine
Aside from Jax's tragic fate, the bulk of the rest of the episode is dedicated to Caine. After being deleted, he awakens in the void and is forced to come to terms with himself in much the same way the other characters are. He then accesses the internet and uses that to check in on the lives of the real-world counterparts of everyone in the circus, who all seem happy and successful (interestingly, eve Jax's real-world counterpart turns out better out there). He realizes he was wrong for forcing his will onto the gang, gives up much of his power by releasing the blue AI, and returns to make amends with everyone.
I personally like that Caine isn't just permanently dead, and I think him learning to live alongside the others as an equal is a really interesting and important aspect of the story. That said, the way his story is handled here is also where my main critiques of the finale come in. To be precise, there are two pretty important things that aren't really explained, and I feel the story definitely suffers for that.
First off, why isn't Caine dead? He was deleted. Why did that send him to the void? Is that just where the circus's recycling bin function is? That could've worked as a perfectly fine explanation, but if it is the reason, I would've liked for it to actually be pointed out in the episode. As-is, his survival feels a bit arbitrary without an explanation.
Secondly, and the much bigger issue, is what causes Caine's change of heart. We see him struggle with his own anger at the crew for deleting him, but he overcomes these urges and ultimately forgives them. My question is... why? What spurs him to take such a complete 180 in his worldview? This is a very important crux of his arc, but it's just kind of... missing.
Another notable missing link in the finale is Bubble. Viewers that payed very close attention in the penultimate episode noticed an interesting detail in the scene where Caine is deleted—that it's Bubble, of all characters, that interferes with what Kinger's trying to do and ultimately causes Caine's death. It feels odd that such a deliberate detail goes completely unmentioned in the finale—not only is Kinger under the impression that Caine himself was interfering rather than Bubble, but the soapy little bastard doesn't even appear in the finale except briefly as an actual, featureless bubble in the void.
Given how he acts in hjsakldfhl (episode 8), there are a few possibilities for what Bubble actually was. Maybe he was the manifestation of the blue AI lashing out at Caine for consuming it? Maybe he wasn't a unique individual at all, but just the manifestation of Caine's insecurities. The lack of a clear answer seems intentional, whereas the lack of any acknowledgment of Bubble's involvement in Caine's deletion feels more like a mistake. I almost suspect that there were originally plans for deeper involvement form Bubble in the finale, but these were scrapped and the detail in hjsakldfhl was left in on accident.
I see missed potential in Bubble's complete absence here, as I think he could have perfectly filled the currently-vacant role of the catalyst for Caine's complete change of heart. Perhaps Bubble could try to manipulate Caine into violence again, only for him to realize what's going on and then turn good. Perhaps it could've been revealed to Caine that Bubble was actually the one who caused his deletion. Maybe Caine could've realized what Bubble was and removed him. In any case, none of that happened, leaving a Bubble-shaped hole at the apex of Caine's character arc.
Conclusion
The Amazing Digital Circus definitely isn't a perfect show—none are. Caine's arc feels a bit incomplete to me, and there are some mysteries I would've liked to learn more about and some things I would've liked to explore in more depth. Gooseworx was a ruthlessly efficient showrunner who made a concerted effort to avoid TADC having any filler, and while that came with some costs, she ultimately succeeded, and the result is a very unique show with a great message, and one that feels true to the creator's intent. Far too many shows nowadays fall victim to homogenization at the hands of out-of-touch executives; TADC manages to remain true to itself, and it's all the better for it.
Overall, I quite enjoyed the finale, and I think the show as a whole is pretty damn good. It has some stellar animation, really fun ideas, an interesting premise, and does an amazing job of exploring its characters. The finale does a pretty great job of wrapping everything up, and I think the show got a perfect ending for the messages it wants to impart.
Comments
Post a Comment